Is Paying More for an Updated Home Worth It? Here’s How to Decide

Inner Circle • March 11, 2025

If money were no object, would you Fix up this house?

If you’re in the market to buy a home, you probably want to negotiate the best price possible. But in today’s market, getting the best deal isn’t just about negotiating the lowest price—it’s about making a smart financial decision that balances cost, convenience, and long-term value.

Even if you’ve just started your home search, you’ve probably noticed that updated homes are often difficult to find and sell faster and at higher prices than homes that need some sprucing up. But how much more may not be so obvious…

Well, according to a recent press release, homes that are “remodeled” currently sell for nearly 4% more than expected, as opposed to last year when they only contributed to a 0.8% sale price premium.

This demand for updated homes signals a shift from the past when buyers were more willing to take on fixer-uppers. But does that mean paying a premium for a move-in-ready home is the best choice for you? Not always. The key is understanding when paying a premium for an updated home is worth every penny, and when rolling up your sleeves and tackling a few projects might be the better move.

The Math Behind Move-In-Ready Homes: Why Paying More Pays Off

For many buyers, choosing a home that needs work was once an appealing way to get more house for the money. But with today’s financing rates and inflation driving up renovation costs, that strategy isn’t always as cost-effective as it used to be.

The press release cited above also mentioned that fixer-uppers now sell for 7.3% less than comparable move-in-ready homes, which is the largest discount in three years. On the surface, that sounds like an opportunity. But the reality is that rising material and labor costs can quickly erase those savings. A kitchen remodel alone can easily exceed $50,000, and unexpected repairs often push budgets even higher. In some cases, paying a little more for a home that’s already updated can actually be the more affordable long-term option.

That doesn’t mean fixer-uppers are off the table. But if you’re considering one, it’s important to approach it with a realistic renovation budget, and an understanding that costs can change quickly. The home that seems like a better deal could become a financial headache if renovation prices climb beyond your expectations.

From an investment perspective, the financial math behind home improvements rarely favors the buyer who tackles renovations themselves. According to the 2024 Cost vs. Value Report, most remodeling projects don’t even provide a dollar-for-dollar return, let alone a profit. While minor updates—like replacing your garage door or front door—often offer solid ROI, big-ticket renovations like full kitchen overhauls or high-end bathroom remodels rarely recoup their full cost in resale value. And let’s be honest, when people think “updated,” new kitchens and bathrooms are the types of things buyers envision, not a couple of doors.

That’s one reason why many buyers are willing to pay more upfront. Instead of dealing with renovation stress, unexpected costs, and the hassle of living in a construction zone, they’re choosing the convenience of a move-in-ready home. And with the added bonus of being able to finance that cost over 30 years, the monthly payment difference might not be as significant as it seems at first glance, and likely more appealing than having to dip into the savings account or rack up the credit card bill.

When Paying More Makes Sense (And When It Doesn’t)

So, should you be willing to stretch your budget for an updated home? It depends. Here are a few things to consider:

When it makes sense to pay more:

  • You don’t have the time, patience, or expertise for renovations. Even minor projects can take months and often go over budget.
  • You want cost predictability. With an updated home, you’re not rolling the dice on how much renovations will actually cost.
  • The updates are worth more than the premium you’re paying. If you can buy an updated house for less than it would cost you to update any other options available to you, it’s likely a smart financial decision.
  • There just aren’t a lot of updated homes that come on the market. If renovated homes are few and far between, paying more for the opportunity to buy one can be money well-spent.

When buying a home that needs work might be the better move:

  • You have renovation experience or trusted contractors. If you’re handy and able to do the work yourself, or you’re able to hire contractors at a reasonable price, you may be able to save significantly.
  • You’re comfortable living through renovations. Some projects, like painting or flooring, can be done room-by-room over time, making it easier to live around. But if you need to do major kitchen or bathroom renovations, or gut the entire house, you’ll either need to be comfortable living through the chaos, or have a place to stay in the meantime.
  • You’re in a market where fixer-upper discounts are larger. In some areas, the price gap between updated and non-updated homes makes renovations a more viable option. If you can get a house that needs work at a substantial discount, and do the work for less than it would cost to buy an updated one, it might be worth the effort.
  • There just aren’t a lot of updated homes that come on the market. If renovated homes are few and far between, and you’re having trouble getting your offers accepted due to stiff competition for the few updated homes, it might make sense to buy one that needs work.

Every buyer’s situation is different, and there are cases where buying a home that needs work can still be a good investment. The key is to go in with clear expectations and a solid understanding of the true costs involved.

Working with a great real estate agent can help you evaluate your options and make a decision that aligns with your goals and budget. They can:

  • Help you compare updated and fixer-upper homes in your target market to see where the best opportunities lie.
  • Connect you with contractors and help you gather renovation cost estimates so you know what to expect before making an offer.
  • Help craft offers that give you a competitive advantage without overpaying.

The Takeaway:

Paying more for a move-in-ready home might seem like a splurge, but in reality, it’s often the smartest financial move. The best deal isn’t always about getting the lowest price—it’s about getting the best value.
If you’re looking at a fixer-upper, make sure the discount justifies the work and expense required. If you’re leaning toward a move-in-ready home, know that you’re not just paying for convenience—you’re paying for financial predictability and peace of mind.
No matter which route you choose, the right strategy can help you make a decision that stands the test of time. And that’s where working with an experienced real estate agent can make all the difference.


Share this post

Why So Many Homeowners Are Downsizing Right Now

By KCM • February 19, 2026
Why So Many Homeowners Are Downsizing Right Now For a growing number of homeowners, retirement isn’t some distant idea anymore. It’s starting to feel very real. According to Realtor.com and the Census, nearly 12,000 people will turn 65 every day for the next two years . And the latest data shows as many as 15% of those older Americans are planning to retire in 2026. And another 23% will do the same in 2027. If you’re considering retiring soon too, here’s what you should be thinking about. Why Downsize? Now's the perfect time to reflect on what you want your life to look like in retirement. Because even though your finances will be going through a big change, you don’t necessarily want to feel like you’re living with less . But odds are, what you do want is for life to feel easier . Easier to enjoy. Easier to manage. Easier to maintain day-to-day. The Top Reasons People Over 60 Move You can see these benefits show up in the data when you look at why people over 60 are moving. The National Association of Realtors (NAR) finds the top 4 reasons aren’t about timing the market or chasing top dollar. They’re about lifestyle: Being closer to children, grandchildren, or long-time friends so it’s easier to spend more time with the people who matter most Wanting a smaller, more functional home with fewer stairs and easier upkeep Retiring and no longer needing to live near the office, so it’s easier to move wherever you want Opting for something smaller to reduce monthly expenses tied to utilities, insurance, and maintenance No matter the reason, the theme is the same: downsizing isn’t about giving something up. It’s about gaining control and choosing simplicity. And it brings peace of mind to know your home fits the years ahead, not the years behind. And the best part? It’s more financially feasible now than many homeowners would expect. The #1 Thing Helping So Many Homeowners Downsize Here’s the part that makes it possible. Thanks to how much home values have grown over the years, many longtime homeowners are realizing they’re in a stronger position than they thought to make that move. According to Cotality , the average homeowner today has about $299,000 in home equity . And for older Americans, that number is often even higher – simply because they’ve lived in their homes longer. When you stay in one place for years (or even decades), two things happen at the same time: Your home value has time to grow. Your mortgage balance shrinks or disappears altogether. That combination creates more options than you’d expect, even in today’s market. So, whether you just retired, or you're about to, it's not too soon to start thinking about what comes next. Sure, it can be hard to leave the house you made so many years of memories in, but maybe it’s time to close one chapter to open a new one that’s just as exciting. Bottom Line Downsizing is about setting yourself up for what comes next – on your terms. If retirement is on the horizon and you’ve started wondering what your current house (and your equity) could make possible, the first step isn’t selling. It’s understanding your options. Let’s talk. A simple, no-pressure conversation can help you see what downsizing might look like – and whether it makes sense for you.

You May Not Want To Skip Over That House That’s Been Sitting on the Market

By KCM • February 18, 2026
The body content of your post goes here. To edit this text, click on it and delete this default text and start typing your own or paste your own from a different source.

A 50-Year Mortgage Might Arrive Soon—Here’s How to Decide if It’s Right for You

By The Lighter Side of Real Estate • February 15, 2026
You’ve probably seen the buzz lately about 50-year mortgages possibly hitting the U.S. market soon. If you haven’t come across it yet, you probably will—whether in a headline, a newsfeed scroll, or it’ll just be an option the next time you’re house hunting. At face value, it sounds like a pretty sweet deal for anyone feeling squeezed by prices and rates. Stretch the payments out over half a century, and suddenly that monthly bill looks a whole lot friendlier. What’s not to love, right? Well, that depends on your perspective. So before deciding whether this could be a game-changer or just another gimmick, let’s make sure you’ve got enough info to have an informed opinion… Lower Payments? Yes. Lower Costs? Not Exactly. For many, the appeal comes down to affordability. A longer loan term could help buyers qualify for homes that might otherwise be out of reach, or simply make monthly payments more comfortable. That part is true, but where there’s a “gimme” there’s a “gotcha.” While the monthly payment may drop, the total cost over time can skyrocket. Stretching a loan over half a century means paying additional interest for half a century. The “savings” you feel each month could easily be swallowed up—and then some—by what you’ll ultimately pay in interest. Just Another “New” Option A 50-year mortgage might sound new and exciting, but it’s really just another option that isn’t currently offered. (Well, at least not all that often.) Buyers already have plenty of choices when it comes to loan terms: 10-, 15-, 20-, and 30-year mortgages are all standard options. Add in the mix of fixed-rate and adjustable-rate structures, and you’ve got a wide range of combinations designed to fit different financial situations. But more often than not, people lean toward the 30-year fixed rate loans. Technically, 40- and even 50-year mortgages already exist, though they’re rare in the U.S. and typically not backed by government programs. According to The White Coat Investor , they’re far more common in Europe, where ultra-long-term loans have been part of the financial landscape for years. A Matter of Perspective Whether a 50-year loan sounds appealing often comes down to your personal philosophy, and your tolerance for long-term debt. Some buyers lean toward shorter-term loans—like 15 or 20-year mortgages—because they want to own their home free and clear sooner and pay less in interest. Someone taking this approach, especially with a 15-year fixed or adjustable-rate mortgage, is often very disciplined about paying extra each month to chip away at the principal. To them, the vast majority of people opting for a 30-year fixed loan might look like they’re squandering money by stretching payments out unnecessarily and paying far more interest than they need to. On the flip side, 30-year borrowers often see the world differently. They value lower monthly payments and the flexibility it provides—whether to invest elsewhere, cover lifestyle costs, or just have breathing room in the budget. To them, those who aggressively tackle a 15-year loan might seem either a little extreme… or just downright wealthy to be able to afford such high payments. So, just like 15-year buyers might shake their heads at 30-year loans, 30-year borrowers will likely question a 50-year term. The point is, there’s no “right” choice. It’s about what makes you comfortable financially and psychologically. Is It Worth the Monthly Savings? Whether the monthly savings makes sense really depends on your perspective and personal situation. Everyone’s circumstances are different, so this is a question only you can answer for yourself. When you’re considering what type of loan and terms to choose, you’ll need to crunch the numbers at that moment—current rates, your credit score, and other factors will all play a role. But to give you some general perspective, HousingWire did some math you might find useful. According to the article, stretching a loan out to 50 years might shave around $100–$200 off your monthly payment compared to a 30-year mortgage. That’s not nothing—it could make a tight budget feel a little more comfortable. However, because you’re paying interest for an extra 20 years (or more), the total cost over the life of the loan can balloon dramatically. In the examples they gave, the interest payments were more than double what they would have been with a 30-year loan. And we’re talking hundreds of thousands of dollars. That “nice little savings” each month comes at the expense of paying far more in the long run. So yes, you’ll feel relief each month with a lower payment, but over decades, your home ends up costing a lot more than the purchase price. That’s the trade-off. A 50-year mortgage isn’t inherently bad; it’s just a choice between short-term comfort and long-term savings. And it’s a choice worth thinking through carefully before signing anything. The Takeaway: The idea of a 50-year mortgage might sound like a silver bullet for housing affordability, but the reality is more nuanced. Sure, it could make monthly payments a bit lighter—but it could also cost much more in the long run and potentially nudge home prices even higher. As with most things in real estate, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It’s not necessarily right or wrong, it’s about what’s right for you. The key is to understand exactly what you’re signing up for before committing to a loan that could last longer than most careers.
Show More